Razer claims optical gaming keyboards are more precise than Hall effect ones because magnets are ‘hard to control’

2025-08-14 09:39:00
www.pcgamer.com

I’ve been using a Hall effect keyboard for quite a while, and I’m keenly aware that this switch technology is the most popular for gamers right now. However, a while ago I spoke with Razer product manager Dexter Tan about optical keyboards, and he argued that optical is actually better.

Both kinds of tech allow for analogue input, meaning keyboard switches don’t just measure a binary ‘off’ or ‘on’, but instead can measure how far down each key has been pressed. This, of course, can allow for analogue input in racing games, for instance, but it also lets you use your keyboard in a more traditional ‘pressed’/’not pressed’ manner, but with more control over how far down each key gets actuated.

One of the main things this has allowed is rapid trigger, which is where you can re-press a key as soon as you start letting up from the last key press, without having to go up a certain distance before re-pressing. This allows for faster reactions in games. Or, you could just set a static actuation distance at exactly the key travel distance you want for each key.

Both optical and Hall effect technologies allow you to do these things. Optical was around before Hall effect, at least as far as mainstream gaming keyboards from mainstream brands are concerned. But over the last few years we’ve seen companies move to Hall effect, with some of the best gaming keyboards using this technology.

Razer, however, reckons optical is better. The reason, the company says, is primarily due to the inherent nature of magnetism and optical technologies. Hall effect switches use magnets to measure how far the switch has travelled, while optical uses infrared light.

A chart comparing optical vs Hall effect switch precision, with optical having a more linear and straight precision line compared to the curved precision line for Hall effect

(Image credit: Razer)

Tan explains: “Magnets are a little bit volatile, they’re hard to control” which leads to “variations and deviations” in consistency between different Hall effect switches.

Optical switches, on the other hand, are apparently easier to keep consistent because you can precisely control the amount of light that goes through each switch. Essentially optical switches have cut-outs in them that change the amount of light that can pass through depending on how far down it’s pressed.

In other words, it’s the physical dimensions—the shape of the cut-out—which determines the precision with which the key depression can be measured. This, according to Razer, can be much more precise than getting the magnets in each switch to exhibit the same amount of magnetism, especially as the company says it tests and calibrates each switch right before packaging.

Razer’s testing claims to show that this bears out in practice, with optical switches measuring the travel distance more accurately throughout the entire key press. You can see the straighter line in the graph belongs to the optical switch, rather than the Hall effect one.

Razer's latest Huntsman V3 Pro TKL gaming keyboard on a desk.

(Image credit: Future)

Razer also claims optical switches are more reliable as they’re less sensitive to environmental factors, and also more performant in general thanks to lower latency. But it’s really the precision element that the company lays on heavy.

I suppose the main question I have is: how many players will notice the difference? I can only just about notice the benefit to Hall effect over standard mechanical, let alone any supposed difference between Hall effect and optical. But I’m not a young pro player with lightning-quick reactions. Razer admits that it’s found that only some players can tell the difference between optical and non-optical keyboards.

The company also admits that optical switches require more power, which might be a problem for wireless keyboards. But wireless keyboards are quite niche anyway—most people are fine leaving their keyboard plugged in and stationary—so I suppose this isn’t much of a downside. RGB lighting is still far more of an energy hog than the infrared in optical switches is.

At any rate, this precision difference might be something to look into if you’re one of the few ultra-competitive gamers looking to eke out as much performance as possible. I’m not sure how we’d test it, as end-users, though, beyond simple feel. On that front, my ageing fingers are happy either way, with Hall effect or optical or heck, even just plain old mechanical.

Plus, there are new switch technologies emerging, such as TMR and induction. On the former, Tan says this still suffers some of the same limitations as Hall effect because it’s magnetic, but with induction it’s too early to tell and there’s not enough data. Some other companies are already looking towards the latter for the future, though, and if that’s anything to go by then the optical vs Hall effect debate might be redundant in the end.

Asus ROG Strix Scope II 96 wireless keyboard

Best gaming keyboard 2025

Source Link

Take your gaming to the next level! The Redragon S101 RGB Backlit Gaming Keyboard is an Amazon’s Choice product that delivers incredible value. This all-in-one PC Gamer Value Kit includes a Programmable Backlit Gaming Mouse, perfect for competitive gaming or casual use.

With 46,015 ratings, an average of 4.6 out of 5 stars, and over 4K+ bought in the past month, this kit is trusted by gamers everywhere! Available now for just $39.99 on Amazon. Plus, act fast and snag an exclusive 15% off coupon – but hurry, this offer won’t last long!

Score this incredible deal now!

Unlock unlimited streaming with a free Amazon Prime trial!
Sign up today!

Help Power Techcratic’s Future – Scan To Support

If Techcratic’s content and insights have helped you, consider giving back by supporting the platform with crypto. Every contribution makes a difference, whether it’s for high-quality content, server maintenance, or future updates. Techcratic is constantly evolving, and your support helps drive that progress.

As a solo operator who wears all the hats, creating content, managing the tech, and running the site, your support allows me to stay focused on delivering valuable resources. Your support keeps everything running smoothly and enables me to continue creating the content you love. I’m deeply grateful for your support, it truly means the world to me! Thank you!

BITCOIN

Bitcoin Logo